[I also have never seen Casablanca. I am a classic movie failiure!!]

. . . oh.

[that adds something complicated to the mix. his brows knit together tightly, nose wrinkled, as he contemplates what to make of this new plot information]

Then. . . I imagine he is struggling with the decision, right? [tryin' to call the ENTIRE MOVIE PLOT just from Anna's description, you're no fun Will] That he would like to reach out for love again, but is too afraid of being hurt a second time.